BTC
71,230.21 USD
+4.79%
ETH
2,477.20 USD
+3.19%
XRP
0.52110687 USD
+3.46%
BCH
348.97 USD
+5.91%
ADA
0.33985322 USD
+3.79%
XLM
0.09447246 USD
+3.69%
NEO
9.47 USD
+6.14%
LTC
66.87 USD
+1.62%
EOS
0.43126973 USD
+5.16%
XEM
0.01597003 USD
+5.15%
IOTA
0.11096520 USD
+6.08%
DASH
22.50 USD
+4.42%
XMR
158.99 USD
-0.45%
TRX
0.16203643 USD
-0.53%
ICX
0.12577464 USD
+5.99%
ETC
18.52 USD
+5.12%
QTUM
2.24 USD
+6.13%
BTG
21.94 USD
+5.19%
VET
0.02073758 USD
+6.44%
LSK
0.76759151 USD
+5.74%
USDT
1.00 USD
+0.36%
OMG
0.22842100 USD
+6.06%
STEEM
0.16039785 USD
+5.61%
ZEC
38.76 USD
+4.26%
SC
0.00436157 USD
+4.45%
BNB
576.09 USD
+3.99%
XVG
0.00351945 USD
+8.39%
SNT
0.02421126 USD
+4.02%
ZRX
0.30276273 USD
+7.17%
REP
0.27026102 USD
-3.06%
KCS
9.18 USD
+3.37%
WAVES
0.97965434 USD
+5.09%
MKR
1,151.23 USD
+0.34%
DCR
11.76 USD
+7.48%
BAT
0.15997554 USD
+6.13%
DGB
0.00555801 USD
+6.84%
LRC
0.11820551 USD
+7.02%
GAS
3.64 USD
+5.20%
KNC
0.42392277 USD
+6.20%
DENT
8.33218e-4 USD
+8.86%
POWR
0.19549211 USD
+4.53%
SYS
0.09336149 USD
+10.82%
BNT
0.49110168 USD
+5.35%
REQ
0.08864503 USD
+4.59%
GNO
208.62 USD
+1.37%
LINK
11.04 USD
+7.40%
QSP
0.00185229 USD
-1.18%
CVC
0.12071364 USD
+4.42%
RLC
1.55 USD
+6.23%
ENJ
0.13738978 USD
+7.79%
STORJ
0.44121718 USD
+7.30%
ANT
6.40 USD
-2.68%
THETA
1.13 USD
+9.25%
ZEN
7.38 USD
+4.17%
MANA
0.28192049 USD
+5.73%
MLN
15.07 USD
+4.12%
DNT
0.03430000 USD
+2.69%
MOON
0.10630244 USD
+4.19%
AMP
0.00364200 USD
+5.01%
GTC
0.58980441 USD
+6.92%
NMR
14.58 USD
+7.19%
STX
1.58 USD
+7.74%
LEO
6.08 USD
-0.04%
GMT
0.12601891 USD
+5.64%
POLIS
0.13339285 USD
+19.08%
DOT
3.94 USD
+4.68%
DAI
1.01 USD
+0.69%
XCN
0.00136347 USD
+16.01%
UNI
7.52 USD
+10.13%
ATOM
4.29 USD
+8.69%
GRT
0.14357945 USD
+8.25%
LUNA
0.33091697 USD
+9.39%
DAR
0.14308779 USD
+9.70%
SCRT
0.18170549 USD
+8.11%
IMX
1.12 USD
+4.69%
ARB
0.50466241 USD
+6.00%
OCEAN
0.54942182 USD
+12.23%
ZIL
0.01378688 USD
+6.60%
TRAC
0.61569349 USD
+2.96%
MDT
0.04131607 USD
+7.11%
HOT
0.00159633 USD
+8.66%
XTZ
0.62830539 USD
+5.72%
FIL
3.48 USD
+5.39%
BIT
0.60004901 USD
+5.70%
GMX
21.36 USD
+6.01%
ZBC
0.00384000 USD
+9.40%
HIGH
1.18 USD
+7.96%
OP
1.45 USD
+6.46%
ERN
1.98 USD
+4.07%
NANO
0.80441885 USD
+3.66%
WBTC
71,606.31 USD
+5.38%
HT
0.20963626 USD
-4.65%
OKB
38.55 USD
+3.45%
BSV
48.41 USD
+6.39%
DOGE
0.18391447 USD
+12.80%
USDC
1.01 USD
+0.77%
OXT
0.06307896 USD
+5.18%
ALGO
0.11714137 USD
+6.23%
BAND
1.05 USD
+7.45%
BTT
8.283e-7 USD
+3.27%
FET
1.29 USD
+13.11%
KAVA
0.32015752 USD
+7.42%
USDP
1.01 USD
+0.89%
PAXG
2,752.58 USD
+0.43%
REN
0.03288810 USD
+6.74%
AAVE
141.14 USD
+9.13%
YFI
4,703.93 USD
+4.38%
MATIC
0.30821706 USD
+4.99%
ICP
7.60 USD
+7.70%
SOL
172.02 USD
+8.73%
SUSHI
0.65115572 USD
+7.87%
UMA
2.20 USD
+5.50%
SNX
1.34 USD
+6.43%
CRV
0.24403954 USD
+8.01%
COMP
42.54 USD
+3.08%
CELO
0.59711436 USD
+8.78%
KSM
16.15 USD
+6.80%
NKN
0.06549079 USD
+6.55%
SHIB
1.86377e-5 USD
+9.32%
SKL
0.03371754 USD
+8.58%
SAND
0.24288070 USD
+6.20%
UST
0.02151571 USD
+6.85%
AVAX
24.77 USD
+8.60%
IOTX
0.03783700 USD
+3.95%
AXS
4.58 USD
+5.49%
XYO
0.00498140 USD
+3.67%
ANKR
0.02405818 USD
+6.36%
CHZ
0.05860468 USD
+6.64%
LPT
9.88 USD
+7.27%
COTI
0.08794540 USD
+8.21%
KEEP
0.09445384 USD
-1.84%
GALA
0.01967621 USD
+11.10%
CRO
0.07299547 USD
+2.81%
ACHP
0.01860387 USD
+7.16%
JASMY
0.01823048 USD
+9.66%
SLP
0.00270862 USD
+10.60%
APE
0.99764681 USD
+7.82%
BUSD
0.99945408 USD
+0.01%
CAKE
1.67 USD
+4.60%
EGLD
24.11 USD
+8.31%
ENS
16.07 USD
+7.24%
FTM
0.61082167 USD
+10.25%
FTT
1.69 USD
+6.40%
HBAR
0.04733098 USD
+9.83%
MBOX
0.14530787 USD
+5.77%
MINA
0.49336125 USD
+8.01%
MOVR
8.86 USD
+7.57%
NEAR
3.93 USD
+7.59%
NEXO
0.99303932 USD
+4.48%
POLS
0.25095045 USD
+7.91%
QNT
58.67 USD
+3.41%
QUICK
0.03430235 USD
+7.14%
RUNE
4.88 USD
+13.44%
RVN
0.01683679 USD
+5.93%
WAXP
0.03015719 USD
+5.92%
WRX
0.11425499 USD
+7.04%
XEC
3.33021e-5 USD
+7.33%
CEL
0.22256342 USD
+2.90%
ALPACA
0.13047401 USD
+7.36%
AUDIO
0.11655236 USD
+4.80%
AVA
0.44387037 USD
+6.68%
CHR
0.15945249 USD
+8.97%
CKB
0.01238351 USD
+6.78%
CLV
0.02651579 USD
+4.46%
FARM
38.22 USD
+6.79%
FLOW
0.51457700 USD
+6.67%
GLMR
0.15608063 USD
+3.47%
IDEX
0.03318596 USD
+3.76%
INJ
17.94 USD
+8.58%
JOE
0.30638676 USD
+8.63%
MIR
0.01302666 USD
-1.64%
POLY
0.06005955 USD
+2.28%
PYR
2.28 USD
+3.59%
RARE
0.13278518 USD
+35.00%
RAY
3.29 USD
+0.34%
ROSE
0.06361680 USD
+6.67%
SFP
0.65307524 USD
+2.78%
SRM
0.02759546 USD
+7.75%
STMX
0.00509191 USD
+8.20%
SUN
0.01768449 USD
+5.54%
SXP
0.26350437 USD
+8.96%
VGX
0.01032219 USD
-1.38%
WOO
0.17333791 USD
+8.95%
YGG
0.43624338 USD
+7.30%
LUNC
8.88519e-5 USD
+6.08%
APT
8.75 USD
+7.43%
MASK
3.00 USD
+14.34%
DYDX
0.95128753 USD
+5.61%
CTSI
0.12048267 USD
+6.84%
CVX
1.54 USD
+4.63%
FORTH
2.87 USD
+5.88%
LDO
1.00 USD
+5.95%
METIS
38.56 USD
+7.10%
RBN
0.30186000 USD
+0.60%
SAMO
0.00779904 USD
+6.41%
SPELL
5.243139e-4 USD
+8.26%
1INCH
0.24139980 USD
+5.23%
ALCX
13.74 USD
+5.24%
ALICE
0.97050955 USD
+5.45%
API3
1.49 USD
+8.95%
ARPA
0.04272160 USD
+6.22%
ASTR
0.05383518 USD
+7.75%
BADGER
2.77 USD
+5.31%
BAL
1.78 USD
+3.82%
BICO
0.22296449 USD
+1.47%
BOBA
0.17353270 USD
+2.03%
BOND
1.41 USD
+8.44%
BTRST
0.31500000 USD
-0.61%
C98
0.11625755 USD
+7.30%
CELR
0.01121275 USD
+7.73%
DIA
0.84106592 USD
+7.03%
ETHW
3.15 USD
+15.99%
GAL
1.72 USD
+2.11%
GHST
0.89521128 USD
+2.86%
GLM
0.29189046 USD
+6.76%
HFT
0.11939132 USD
+5.19%
ILV
33.09 USD
+6.41%
KP3R
16.64 USD
-20.46%
LCX
0.09315726 USD
+7.57%
LOKA
0.16823661 USD
+8.11%
LQTY
0.85168264 USD
+7.01%
MC
0.43148656 USD
-25.42%
MPL
21.76 USD
+13.69%
MXC
0.00479575 USD
+2.27%
OGN
0.09366028 USD
+18.15%
PERP
0.59807315 USD
+5.25%
PDA
0.03778575 USD
+4.92%
POND
0.01039155 USD
+6.12%
RAD
1.12 USD
+5.18%
RARI
1.43 USD
+0.91%
RLY
0.00326463 USD
-3.10%
RNDR
4.58 USD
+7.15%
RPL
9.13 USD
+1.77%
STG
0.25953585 USD
+4.81%
SYN
0.49524595 USD
+9.41%
T
0.02065648 USD
+6.87%
TLM
0.00918471 USD
+6.87%
TRU
0.06988572 USD
+9.70%
UNFI
1.37 USD
-3.98%
AR
14.18 USD
+7.92%
FXS
1.71 USD
+3.76%
GUSD
1.00 USD
-0.41%
KLAY
0.12538984 USD
-0.68%
TUSD
1.00 USD
+0.74%
XDC
0.02664087 USD
-0.39%
XRD
0.01496659 USD
+2.13%
USDD
1.00 USD
+0.43%
TON
4.77 USD
+1.44%
TWT
0.96342593 USD
+3.62%
HNT
6.20 USD
+9.56%
OSMO
0.40883318 USD
+7.17%
ATLAS
0.00235041 USD
+9.17%
BFC
0.03799990 USD
+2.99%
BLUR
0.20798761 USD
+12.58%
BABYDOGE
2.201645e-9 USD
+7.53%
CEEK
0.02582547 USD
+4.09%
ELON
1.397e-7 USD
+7.92%
FLOKI
1.313912e-4 USD
+10.52%
KISHU
2.813252e-10 USD
+7.32%
LOOKS
0.03858606 USD
+13.91%
ONE
0.01164073 USD
+7.65%
RACA
1.776901e-4 USD
+9.06%
REEF
0.00140063 USD
+9.43%
SAITAMA
5.99151e-5 USD
+33.20%
WIN
7.44981e-5 USD
+2.28%
AGLD
1.29 USD
+3.42%
TOKE
0.44034342 USD
-4.39%
GST
0.01051710 USD
+3.57%
CSPR
0.00679254 USD
+6.66%
GT
8.62 USD
+3.08%
PEPE
9.0687e-6 USD
+13.01%
BLZ
0.09437652 USD
+7.30%
FLR
0.01262334 USD
+3.10%
FIS
0.29493459 USD
-1.16%
GNS
1.65 USD
+6.33%
ID
0.37468181 USD
+6.30%
AXL
0.69582648 USD
+6.66%
WEMIX
0.77947750 USD
+6.93%
VLX
0.00772444 USD
+4.52%
HMT
0.02052836 USD
-1.07%
DG
0.04039257 USD
-5.04%
SWEAT
0.00853022 USD
+21.77%
BONE
0.38009569 USD
+8.59%
SANTOS
4.43 USD
+6.02%
SUI
2.11 USD
+12.79%
TVK
0.07132378 USD
+0.39%
BONK
2.01847e-5 USD
+12.37%
PIT
2.87916e-10 USD
-0.03%
CORE
0.84405925 USD
+6.85%
BRISE
6.97385e-8 USD
+2.48%
KAS
0.11460130 USD
+8.97%
AGIX
0.49668503 USD
+0.29%
XEN
8.032206e-8 USD
+5.87%
HAM
1.800045e-9 USD
+93.76%
TAMA
8.799979e-4 USD
-0.11%
KDA
0.51043250 USD
+7.99%
CFX
0.14256406 USD
+9.90%
VRA
0.00285569 USD
+16.65%
BDX
0.07915217 USD
+1.88%
RDNT
0.04397666 USD
+8.63%
WLD
1.86 USD
+9.41%
FB
0.59598995 USD
-87.60%
PYUSD
1.01 USD
+0.80%
SEI
0.36533769 USD
+6.81%
TOMI
0.01328995 USD
-7.45%
AKT
2.36 USD
+8.04%
MAGIC
0.32925323 USD
+8.09%
ALPHA
0.06804936 USD
+7.24%
ALI
0.00766931 USD
+4.25%
CQT
0.00355173 USD
-1.21%
AERGO
0.09413762 USD
+5.38%
GODS
0.16225020 USD
+6.61%
ACA
0.05319451 USD
+3.91%
LIT
0.59285543 USD
+7.83%
QI
0.01225281 USD
+7.64%
AURORA
0.12343180 USD
+6.78%
XCH
13.20 USD
+6.18%
STRK
0.35772628 USD
+5.26%
MANTA
0.63495201 USD
+8.20%
PYTH
0.35063615 USD
+7.48%
TIA
4.40 USD
+2.88%
ETHFI
1.36 USD
+9.33%
WIF
2.22 USD
+13.28%
ACS
0.00138529 USD
+1.71%
AIOZ
0.41643287 USD
+9.69%
BIGTIME
0.15835901 USD
+6.68%
DYM
1.39 USD
+8.65%
ELA
1.84 USD
+5.30%
JTO
2.06 USD
+10.86%
JUP
0.95405010 USD
+9.40%
ONDO
0.65470627 USD
+8.11%
ORCA
2.34 USD
+1.87%
PRIME
6.59 USD
+2.69%
TRB
56.79 USD
+6.74%
ZETA
0.59234647 USD
+5.90%
USDE
1.01 USD
+0.84%
EETH
2,515.77 USD
+0.89%
SNGLS
4.021e-4 USD
N/A
NU
0.05996004 USD
N/A
DFX
132.61 USD
+7.00%
SMT
1,548.84 USD
+3.41%
CPU
1,395.74 USD
+7.39%
CSC
999.97 USD
+0.06%
CD20
2,045.05 USD
+4.16%
Ad

CoinDesk Podcasts

CoinDesk’s Money Reimagined

Getting Internet Identity Right, 30 Years On

This week, Michael Casey and Sheila Warren talk to Hyperledger's Brian Behlendorf about the future of identity on the...

CoinDesk’s Money Reimagined
[@portabletext/react] Unknown block type "iframe", specify a component for it in the `components.types` prop

This week, Michael Casey and Sheila Warren talk to Hyperledger Executive Director Brian Behlendorf about the future of identity on the internet.

A developer whose three-decade career has seen him deeply involved in efforts to foster a more open internet, Brian grasps, like few others, the nuances of how human beings should live within a rapidly changing digital economy.

Getting Internet Identity Right, 30 Years On

We tend to think of governments, with the data they collect on births, drivers licenses, tax returns and passports, as humanity’s primary identity managers.

Arguably, internet platforms have usurped that role. Some store more identifying records than China – Facebook has 2.7 billion active users; Google manages 1.5 billion email accounts. Just as important, they can tie those records to our online behavior and gather immense predictive power. Facebook’s algorithm even knows if you are going to break up with your partner – before you do.

This isn’t another Facebook-bashing column. It’s just that its all-knowing power highlights how the fundamental human question of identity has changed in the internet age.

It also illustrates why we need a new “self-sovereign” model of identity to match our digital existence and why the latest moves toward that deserve widespread support.

Flawed from the start

An original sin was committed at the internet’s conception: its underlying, decentralized architecture was built without an identity layer.

The internet’s founders had good Intentions. To ensure universal availability, the system controlled access by assigning addresses to computers but was agnostic about the identities of the people, companies and devices using them. As a famous New Yorker cartoon quipped in 1993, “On the internet, nobody knows you’re a dog.”

This became a problem when entrepreneurs started building e-commerce businesses in the 1990s. Users needed to trust the person on the other side of a transaction, which, according to offline practices, meant identifying them to hold them accountable.

So a jury-rigged solution was installed at the internet’s application layer. Certification powers were introduced, allowing web-based companies to gather and verify users’ identifying information. Over time, this gave rise to a new class of immensely powerful gatekeepers.

We ended up in the worst of both worlds. On the one hand, end-users still don’t know who’s controlling disinformation bots. On the other, as CoinDesk’s Ben Powers put it in a great contribution to our “Internet 2030” series, the centralized data-gatherers “not only know you’re a dog, but also what breed you are, what your favorite kibble is and whether you’ve been microchipped.”

This power asymmetry has fueled a severe deterioration in societal trust, and solutions have been hamstrung by a pre-internet mindset. We’ve placed responsibility for policing behavior with intermediaries, which has further empowered centralized data-gatherers.

This contradicts the internet’s decentralized, identity-free base layer, creating unique opportunities for abuse. Web sites accumulate giant honeypots of personal identifying information (PII), which are constantly breached by unidentified hackers.

Meanwhile, even though companies complain about the liability in storing user data, they find it hard to resist surveillance capitalism, the data-exploitation practice that has become the core business model of the internet.

We need a new mindset. Since the internet’s underlying architecture is decentralized, the identity solution must also be decentralized. Control over PII must reside with those to whom it refers – with you and me, in other words. This is the principle behind the “self-sovereign identity” (SSI) movement.

Controlling attributes, not identity

Let’s be clear: This isn’t easy. Identity is an extremely complex concept.

In the metaphysical sense of “who I am,” identity is at once highly personal and completely social. We value a unique selfhood, but it’s meaningless without reference to the society within which that self exists.

It’s also fluid and multilayered. We occupy – or "perform”– different versions of our identity, or personas, depending on context. We all play a different persona in job interviews than the one we play at home with family.

And in the wider economy, where proofs of identity solve the deep-seated challenge of trust, allowing us to transact, what matters is not our selfhood but the distinct attributes that comprise it. Do you have a degree? A driver’s license? A credit score over 740? These are isolated attributes. They are not our identity per se.

With SSI, sophisticated cryptography allows individuals, as sole custodians of their data, to prove they have the credentials that describe their attributes and selectively reveal them in an encrypted form to service providers.

In an oft-cited example conceived by identity expert David Birch, you could legitimately enter a bar after furnishing a cryptographic proof that answers one question: are you over the designated drinking age? The bar owner doesn’t need to know all the other information displayed on your driver’s license: not your name, your address, your license number or even your actual birthday.

ID ideation

A host of entities are working on SSI, from big players like IBM and Microsoft to startups such as Gataca and Hyland Credentials. Some governments, including the Canadian province of British Columbia, are supporting special ID apps for their constituents.

Still, standardization across the internet will be critical. An important piece is the decentralized digital identifier, or DID, being developed within the world wide web consortium, or WC3. Groups of tech and finance heavyweights have also formed associations to promote open-source collaboration, including the Digital Identity Foundation and the Trust Over IP Foundation.

Within the standard SSI model, blockchain technology plays an important but minor role currently. Some SSI projects have dabbled in tokenization to raise funds and incentivize stakeholders such as credential providers. But the troubles caused by the Sovrin Foundation’s token sale have quelled enthusiasm for that.

A blockchain is not used for storing identifying data. That’s up to the individual data owner, who could choose to store it on a hard drive, for example, or with a cloud account they control. Rather, a blockchain is used as a public key registry and management system to prove that the private keys with which a user enables access to encrypted credentials are associated with the right person or company. In this way, a hospital can decode and validate medical records shared by a patient, while keeping its privacy compliance officer satisfied that the patient is indeed authorized to do so.

More important is how SSI could help other blockchain applications. If decentralized finance (DeFi) applications are to spread to traditional finance, for example, there must be a way to identify market participants without inserting a centralized authority into a necessarily decentralized environment.

Human empowerment

The most important use case for SSI lies in protecting our humanity. In an age when data leads to economic domination, shifting control to those who generate it is a really impactful way to empower individuals.

Instead of thinking of digital data as a sinister threat to our privacy, SSI could turn it into an asset they can sell or use to get credit or obtain other services. Think of people who live without credit cards and can’t generate credit scores but whose trail of internet connections – their so-called web of trust – show a history of fulfilling commitments.

Within an SSI framework, we can use our data to safely connect our identity to the society with which it is intrinsically associated. We could map and measure our social connections, capture that data as an attribute and then communicate it to others so they’ll trust us enough to transact.

Courtesy of COVID-19 and the public interest in contact tracing, there’s now an immediate use case for this kind of controlled measurement of social activity. It’s why Hyperledger Executive Director Brian Behlendorf, appearing in this week’s Money Reimagined podcast, argued that the first prominent deployment of SSI would come next year in the form of a “digital yellow card” for vaccination records.

Whether we like it or not, society is digitalized and decentralized. We need an identity system that aligns with that.